Taken as the 10th overall pick of the 2001 NFL Draft, Reynolds had high expectations coming out of Florida State as the Lombardi Award winner. He never made much of an impact, lasting just three seasons and playing in a mere 18 games and recording just three sacks before he was traded by Green Bay to the Colts in 2004 for a draft pick.
2001: Jamal Reynolds

Florida State defensive end Jamal Reynolds poses with the Lombardi Award trophy before an awards ceremony Wednesday, Dec. 6, 2000 in Houston. Reynolds won the Lombardi award as the nation's top college lineman. (AP Photo/Michael Stravato)